Table of Contents: Vendor Scorecard Workbook

This workbook provides a comprehensive framework for evaluating vendor proposals, conducting demos, and synthesizing scores into a final recommendation.

I. Governance & Documentation

Foundational sheets covering the legal, instructional, and methodological rules of the workbook.

Tab Name Brief Recap of Purpose
CopyrightOutlines intellectual property rights and usage permissions.
Read MeHigh-level introduction to the workbook's purpose and version history.
Playbook TermsA glossary of standard definitions and evaluation terminology.
InstructionsStep-by-step guidance for users on how to populate each section.
Elements of ScoringDefines the scoring philosophy and quantitative logic used.
Scoring FlowA roadmap showing how data flows from entry to the final recap.
Copy ProcessBest practices for duplicating tabs without breaking formula links.

II. Setup & Configuration

Configuration sheets where you define your specific project requirements and weights.

Tab Name Brief Recap of Purpose
Structure NeedsUsed to define the primary technical and business categories for the RFP.
Focus on Vital NeedsA prioritization matrix to separate "Must-Haves" from "Nice-to-Haves."
Design QuestionsThe workspace for drafting and refining evaluation questions.
Enter Scoring BasisMaster Config: Sets the 0–5 rating scales and Decision Factor weights.
Track Deleted QuestionsAudit log for questions removed during the internal vetting process.

III. Evaluation & Scoring

The "Live" sheets where evaluators input vendor scores.

Tab Name Brief Recap of Purpose
Score Min. Needs ChecklistA preliminary pass/fail gate for mandatory requirements.
Score Minimum NeedsItemized scoring for baseline vendor capabilities.
Create Vendor ScorecardThe primary data entry sheet for scoring RFP responses and stages.
Create Vendor Scorecard 17An alternate version of the scorecard (likely for additional vendors).

IV. Synthesis & Reporting

Dashboards and narrative areas that aggregate data into a final recommendation.

Tab Name Brief Recap of Purpose
Recap Scores & StatsThe main dashboard; provides dynamic totals and percentage scores.
Recap Scores & Stats 17Summary stats for the alternate vendor scorecard (Tab 17).
Recap SPRONTO NarrativeA section for qualitative commentary and executive summaries.
Recommend VendorFinal ranking of vendors based on weighted quantitative performance.
Recommend Vendor 17Final ranking for the alternate vendor set.
Recommend Vendor - HB"Harvey Ball" visualization for simplified executive reporting.
Recommend Vendor 17 HBHarvey Ball visualization for the alternate vendor set.

V. Reference & Example Library

Pre-populated samples and consensus tools used for training and calibration.

Category Tab Names Included
Example ScorecardsScore Proposals Example, Score Interviews-Demos Example, Score Field Visits Example
Consensus SamplesScore Consensus Example (1 through 6)
System LogicScore Minimum Needs Example, Create Vendor Scorecard Example, Recap Scores & Stats Example, Recommend Vendor Example

VI. Backend Logic

System-level tabs that support the workbook's automated features.

Feature Description
Linked Worksheets-DropdownsPowers the data validation lists throughout the workbook.
Linked Worksheets-ScoresContains background calculations for tab-to-tab linking.